American Rental
Open right now until 6 PM. Call ahead and they will tell you what is on the floor today.
427 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362 (765) 465-4057
Photos from this location's public business profile and the store's own submissions. VRTO does not add photography.
What you can rent here
American Rental is a rent-to-own retailer that began in 1981 in Bloomington, Indiana, and has been locally owned since. Today it operates 54 stores across five states, including locations in Bedford and Corydon, Indiana, Bardstown and Carrollton, Kentucky, and Athens, Tennessee. Stores carry furniture, appliances, electronics, computers, and mattresses on flexible weekly or monthly lease agreements, with 100% of rent paid going toward ownership and no credit check required at most rent-to-own stores. The chain holds a 4.8 Google rating across more than 14,000 reviews. Compare American Rental on VRTO alongside other rent-to-own stores near you, with hours, ratings, and what each carries.
What this store carries
These are the categories this American Rental carries. Call the store for current prices and terms.
This location
427 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN. Open until 6 PM.
Call (765) 465-4057 Get directionsAmerican Rental will tell you what you qualify for before anything is run, stated by American Rental.
Before you go in
How rent-to-own leases usually work
Typical terms for rent-to-own stores. This store sets its own; always read the agreement before you sign.
What to bring
- Valid photo ID (driver's license, state ID, or passport)
- Proof of income (recent pay stub, bank statement, or benefits letter)
- Proof of residence (utility bill, lease agreement, or mail with your address)
- Personal references (typically 3 to 4 contacts with phone numbers)
How it works
- 1Browse in store and choose from available furniture, appliances, electronics, and more.
- 2Apply with no traditional credit check at most stores. Approval is based on income and residency.
- 3Get approved, often same day, with immediate access to your items.
- 4Delivery or pickup, with free delivery, setup, and ongoing service at most stores.
Typically included with rent-to-own agreements:
Delivery, setup, service, maintenance, return rights, and early purchase options vary by retailer and agreement. Ask the store to provide the complete written terms before signing.
Frequently asked questions
Hours and how to get there
Hours confirmed with the store Nov 1, 2026. Call ahead on a holiday.
Customer reviews
The team goes out of their way to make sure you feel welcome. Super knowledgeable and patient with questions. Great selection and the prices are fantastic. Would absolutely recommend for furniture or home accessories.
The staff there was very courteous and very helpful and very knowledgeable. I appreciate them working with me On figuring out what would be the best fit for my living room. I’m very satisfied with what I got and yes, I would purchase from them again
The stop in the store were very informed and present, but not pushy or overbearing. There was a good selection on the showroom floor. I like shopping in person, so this made selecting our furniture a nice experience. The delivery guys were very patient and helpful. I actually had to remove a door to get the furniture to fit in the room I wanted and they did not make me feel like it was an inconvenience. So far, it's been a good experience purchasing from American Rental.
Quick fast, easy Gary informative the gentleman who also came and put my stuff together. Did a fast phenomenal job. Everything was just great all around. I would highly recommend.
Staff was helpful. They were able to answer questions that I had. The delivery crew was awesome. They set up the washer/dryer and made sure everything was working and balanced
I have payed off a few items.. Devon, Paul and Adam are awesome.. I had to have a major surgery.. American rental texted me n was inquiring how I was doing.. I have not one time had a issue with any of the sales rep.. they are professional but yet caring.. I would highly recommend American Rental..
Other places to try in New Castle, IN
More stores in New Castle
All New Castle storesNearest first. The figure is that store's own Google rating.
Categories at this store
Each opens that category across New Castle. The count is the New Castle stores carrying it.
Related pages
Store details including hours, address, phone number, and product availability are sourced from publicly available retailer data and updated regularly. This information may not reflect recent changes. Always contact the store directly to confirm current hours, inventory, and pricing before visiting. VRTO (Virtual Rent To Own) is a directory and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting as an agent of American Rental or any other rent-to-own company. Reviews and ratings shown are from Google and reflect the opinions of individual reviewers, not VRTO. See our full disclaimer and data collection methodology.
Listing information for American Rental is provided for reference purposes only. VRTO is not affiliated with this store. Contact the store directly to verify hours, inventory, and pricing.