New: Rent-to-Own Sheds & Portable Buildings — 521 dealers, 837 locations
Find stores

American Rental

Closed · Opens 9 AM 4.9 (276 reviews) on Google

1320 Indianapolis Rd, Greencastle, IN 46135

Call (765) 653-2883 Get directions Visit website
Inside American Rental

About American Rental

American Rental is a rent-to-own retailer that began in 1981 in Bloomington, Indiana, and has been locally owned since. Today it operates 54 stores across five states, including locations in Bedford and Corydon, Indiana, Bardstown and Carrollton, Kentucky, and Athens, Tennessee. Stores carry furniture, appliances, electronics, computers, and mattresses on flexible weekly or monthly lease agreements, with 100% of rent paid going toward ownership and no credit check required at most rent-to-own stores. The chain holds a 4.8 Google rating across more than 14,000 reviews. Compare American Rental on VRTO alongside other rent-to-own stores near you, with hours, ratings, and what each carries.

How the lease works here

Payment frequency Weekly or monthly
Typical term 12 to 24 months
Same-as-cash window 90 days
Credit check Not required

Terms are confirmed with the store and can change. Always read the agreement before you sign.

What to bring

  • Valid photo ID (driver's license, state ID, or passport)
  • Proof of income (recent pay stub, bank statement, or benefits letter)
  • Proof of residence (utility bill, lease agreement, or mail with your address)
  • Personal references (typically 3 to 4 contacts with phone numbers)

How it works

  1. 1Browse in store and choose from available furniture, appliances, electronics, and more.
  2. 2Apply with no traditional credit check at most stores. Approval is based on income and residency.
  3. 3Get approved, often same day, with immediate access to your items.
  4. 4Delivery or pickup, with free delivery, setup, and ongoing service at most stores.

Typically included with rent-to-own agreements:

Delivery, setup, service, maintenance, return rights, and early purchase options vary by retailer and agreement. Ask the store to provide the complete written terms before signing.

Frequently asked questions

American Rental offers a variety of products on a rent-to-own basis. Contact the store directly to confirm current inventory and availability.

American Rental is located at 1320 Indianapolis Rd, Greencastle, IN. Check the store hours listed on this page for current opening and closing times, as hours may vary on holidays.

Most rent-to-own stores, including American Rental, do not require a traditional credit check. Approval is typically based on income verification and proof of residency. Contact American Rental directly to confirm their specific requirements.

Return timing, fees, item condition, refunds, and remaining obligations vary by agreement. Contact American Rental to review its written return and early purchase terms.

You can contact the store directly by calling (765) 653-2883 or visiting in person at 1320 Indianapolis Rd, Greencastle, IN.

Hours

Monday 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Tuesday (Today) 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Wednesday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Thursday 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Friday 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Saturday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sunday Closed

Location

1320 Indianapolis Rd, Greencastle, IN 46135

Get directions

Customer reviews

4.9

276 reviews

5
100%
4
0%
3
0%
2
0%
1
0%
Have you visited this store? Write a review on Google
LexieRose Wainman
LexieRose Wainman 2 months ago

I absolutely love the staff of American Rental (Greencastle), there all very approachable and always have good attitudes. There delivery guys are very professional and always have smiles on there faces.

LexieRose Wainman
LexieRose Wainman 2 months ago

I absolutely love the staff of American Rental (Greencastle), there all very approachable and always have good attitudes. There delivery guys are very professional and always have smiles on there faces.

Roger Miller
Roger Miller 3 months ago

Needed new furniture and the Friday after we had a beautiful matching set of reclining sofa and couch. Delivery was easy and painless.

Roger Miller
Roger Miller 3 months ago

Needed new furniture and the Friday after we had a beautiful matching set of reclining sofa and couch. Delivery was easy and painless.

Shannon “Sissy” Schmidt
Shannon “Sissy” Schmidt 4 months ago

I will forever only be going to see Stephanie and her team!! This woman has been a pleasure working with Steph really knows her customers ! I love how they will work with you when times get rough as long as you communicate with them. I love the customer service here 10/10 in my book! Thank you girl!! You are what makes this place a good experience you’re a very good person and I’m glad I came in there !

Shannon “Sissy” Schmidt
Shannon “Sissy” Schmidt 4 months ago

I will forever only be going to see Stephanie and her team!! This woman has been a pleasure working with Steph really knows her customers ! I love how they will work with you when times get rough as long as you communicate with them. I love the customer service here 10/10 in my book! Thank you girl!! You are what makes this place a good experience you’re a very good person and I’m glad I came in there !

Linda Swartz
Linda Swartz 5 months ago

Team was helpful, knowledgeable, and professional. I’ve used them for various household items for my home over a span of 7 years. Always quality items. Would highly recommend.

Heather Sutherlin
Heather Sutherlin 6 months ago

The staff at American Rental is easy to work with. If I have a problem with something I’m purchasing from them they do their best to solve it. Steffeny is awesome and has been really helpful and nice.

Heather Sutherlin
Heather Sutherlin 6 months ago

The staff at American Rental is easy to work with. If I have a problem with something I’m purchasing from them they do their best to solve it. Steffeny is awesome and has been really helpful and nice.

Melissa Rivera
Melissa Rivera 6 months ago

Absolutely would recommend this place.Staff is nice and super helpful. I had Dom last night for drop off. He was amazing, so polite and kind. I definitely will be going back.

Reviews from Google
See all reviews on Google Maps

Compare before you sign

See what other stores near Greencastle charge for the same item.

Compare nearby stores Estimate the total cost

More rent-to-own stores in Greencastle, IN

Data accuracy notice

Store details including hours, address, phone number, and product availability are sourced from publicly available retailer data and updated regularly. This information may not reflect recent changes. Always contact the store directly to confirm current hours, inventory, and pricing before visiting. VRTO (Virtual Rent To Own) is a directory and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting as an agent of American Rental or any other rent-to-own company. Reviews and ratings shown are from Google and reflect the opinions of individual reviewers, not VRTO. See our full disclaimer and data collection methodology.

Listing information for American Rental is provided for reference purposes only. VRTO is not affiliated with this store. Contact the store directly to verify hours, inventory, and pricing.

Call now