Home
Indiana
New Castle
American Rental

American Rental

4.8/5 (243 reviews)

American Rental is a rent-to-own store located at 427 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362. Customers have rated this store 4.8/5 based on 243 reviews.

Photos by Google

/ 5

Address

427 S Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN 47362 Get Directions

Phone

(765) 465-4057

Store Hours

Monday	9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday	9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday	9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday (Today)	9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday	9:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Saturday	9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sunday	Closed

What to Expect at This Store

Visiting a rent-to-own store is straightforward. Here is a general overview of what to bring and how the process typically works. Requirements may vary — contact American Rental directly to confirm.

What to Bring

Valid photo ID — driver's license, state ID, or passport
Proof of income — recent pay stub, bank statement, or benefits letter
Proof of residence — utility bill, lease agreement, or mail with your address
Personal references — typically 3-4 contacts with phone numbers

How It Works

1 Browse in store — choose from available furniture, appliances, electronics, and more
2 Apply — no traditional credit check at most stores; approval is based on income and residency
3 Get approved — many stores offer same-day approval and immediate access to your items
4 Delivery or pickup — most stores include free delivery, setup, and ongoing service/maintenance

Typically included with rent-to-own agreements:

Free delivery and setup, service and maintenance for the life of the agreement, the option to return items at any time without penalty, and an early purchase option (EPO) to buy the item outright before the lease ends. Rent-to-own is not a loan or credit purchase. Specific terms vary by store.

Customer Reviews

4.8

243 reviews

Have you visited this store? Write a review on Google

Michael Saville 2 months ago

The staff there was very courteous and very helpful and very knowledgeable. I appreciate them working with me On figuring out what would be the best fit for my living room. I’m very satisfied with what I got and yes, I would purchase from them again

Stephen Perguson 2 months ago

Staff was helpful. They were able to answer questions that I had. The delivery crew was awesome. They set up the washer/dryer and made sure everything was working and balanced

Debra Crabtree 2 months ago

I have payed off a few items.. Devon, Paul and Adam are awesome.. I had to have a major surgery.. American rental texted me n was inquiring how I was doing.. I have not one time had a issue with any of the sales rep.. they are professional but yet caring.. I would highly recommend American Rental..

Andrea Ross 5 months ago

I've done business with these guys for years now. They're respectful and understanding. I'd recommend going to them to anyone. American Rental has awesome furniture, rugs, and more! Check them out! You won't be disappointed ☺️

Maria Fitzpatrick 5 months ago

It was wonderful.store was warm and welcoming and ful of holiday joy .The drivers were polite and great at what they do hats off to them .All around a great expriance

Tony Lee 6 months ago

The whole experience from signing my lease to my items being delivered went smooth as can be. The staff were all very friendly and everything was delivered at the time they said it would be and everything works as it should. Overall, couldn’t be happier with the whole experience and would highly recommend American Rental to anyone.

Reviews from Google

See all reviews on Google Maps

More Rent-to-Own Stores in New Castle, IN

Rent-A-Center

120 S Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN 47362

(765) 593-0300

furniture appliances electronics computers mattresses +4 more

3.6 (70)

Verified 1 month ago

View Details Visit Website

Frequently Asked Questions

American Rental offers a variety of products on a rent-to-own basis. Contact the store directly to confirm current inventory and availability.

American Rental is located at 427 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN. Check the store hours listed above for current opening and closing times, as hours may vary on holidays.

Most rent-to-own stores, including American Rental, do not require a traditional credit check. Approval is typically based on income verification and proof of residency. Contact American Rental directly to confirm their specific requirements.

Rent-to-own agreements generally allow you to return items at any time without penalty, though you will not receive a refund for payments already made. Policies vary by store — contact American Rental to review their specific return and early buyout terms.

You can contact the store directly by calling (765) 465-4057 or visiting in person at 427 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN.

Data Accuracy Notice

Store details including hours, address, phone number, and product availability are sourced from publicly available retailer data and updated regularly. This information may not reflect recent changes — always contact the store directly to confirm current hours, inventory, and pricing before visiting. VRTO (Virtual Rent To Own) is an independent directory and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting as an agent of American Rental or any other rent-to-own company. Reviews and ratings shown are from Google and reflect the opinions of individual reviewers, not VRTO. See our full disclaimer and data collection methodology.

Listing information for American Rental is provided for reference purposes only. VRTO is not affiliated with this store. Contact the store directly to verify hours, inventory, and pricing.

Call Now